What is Better a Settlement or Trial?

Written by

On May 16, 2023
personal injury attorney, Utah personal injury attorney, Utah car accident lawyer

When pursuing a personal injury case, one important decision to make is whether to settle the case or proceed to trial. Both options have their merits and considerations. Understanding the differences between the two can help you make an informed decision. We will explore the factors to consider when deciding between settling or going to trial for a personal injury case. By understanding the advantages, disadvantages, and potential outcomes of each option, you can make the best choice for your specific circumstances.

The Settlement Option:

  1. Definition and Process:
    • Settlement refers to an agreement reached between the injured party (plaintiff) and the at-fault party or their insurance company (defendant) to resolve the case without going to trial.
    • The negotiation process typically involves discussions and offers between the parties and their attorneys, aiming to reach a mutually acceptable resolution.
  2. Advantages of Settlement:
    • Time and Cost Savings: Settling a case can save considerable time and money compared to a lengthy trial process.
    • Certainty: With a settlement, both parties know the outcome and avoid the uncertainty of trial verdicts.
    • Control: Parties have more control over the outcome and can negotiate terms that meet their specific needs.
    • Privacy: Settlements are typically confidential, preserving the privacy of the parties involved.
  3. Disadvantages of Settlement:
    • Potential Undervaluing: The settlement amount may be lower than what could be obtained through a successful trial verdict.
    • No Appeals: Once a settlement is reached and accepted, there is no opportunity to appeal the decision.
  4. Factors Affecting Settlement Amount:
    • Severity of Injuries and Damages: The extent of your injuries, medical expenses, lost wages, and long-term impacts can influence the settlement amount.
    • Liability: The strength of your evidence and the defendant’s perceived liability can impact the settlement negotiations.
    • Insurance Coverage: The available insurance coverage of the defendant plays a significant role in determining the settlement amount.

Going To Trial:

  1. Definition and Process:
    • Going to trial involves presenting your case before a judge or jury who will determine the outcome and any potential compensation.
    • The trial process involves presenting evidence, witnesses, expert testimonies, and arguments from both sides to support their respective positions.
  2. Advantages of Going to Trial:
    • Potential Higher Compensation: If successful, a trial verdict may result in higher compensation than what could be obtained through settlement negotiations.
    • Establishing Liability: A trial allows for a comprehensive examination of the facts and evidence, enabling the opportunity to prove the defendant’s negligence and liability.
    • Precedent and Public Awareness: Trial verdicts can set legal precedents and draw public attention to important issues.
  3. Disadvantages of Going to Trial:
    • Time and Expenses: Trials can be lengthy, requiring significant time, effort, and financial resources to prepare and present a case effectively.
    • Uncertainty: The outcome of a trial is uncertain, as it depends on the judge or jury’s interpretation of the evidence and the strength of legal arguments.
    • Stress and Emotional Toll: Going through a trial can be emotionally challenging, as it involves reliving the traumatic event and engaging in adversarial proceedings.
  4. Factors Affecting Trial Outcome:
    • Strength of Evidence: The quality and persuasiveness of the evidence presented can greatly influence the trial outcome.
    • Credibility of Witnesses: The credibility of witnesses, including expert witnesses and eyewitnesses, can impact the jury’s assessment of the case.
    • Jury Composition: The attitudes, biases, and experiences of the jury members can influence their verdict.

Speak with an expert attorney

Deciding whether to settle or go to trial in a personal injury case is a significant choice that requires careful consideration. While settlement offers the advantages of time and cost savings, certainty, and control over the outcome, going to trial provides the potential for higher compensation and the opportunity to establish liability through a formal legal process. Ultimately, the decision should be based on personal factors. Such as the strength of your case, the potential settlement offers, the risks and expenses associated with trial, and your personal objectives. Consulting with an experienced personal injury attorney can provide valuable guidance and help you navigate the decision-making process, ensuring you make the best choice to protect your rights and pursue fair compensation for your injuries and damages. Shane Gosdis is determined to get the compensation that you and your case deserve. To schedule a consultation call (385) 429-9960 or email s@gosdis.lawyer today.

You May Also Like…